Warts on Books
BY: PARASURAM DAS
Dec 15, 2013 — UK (SUN) — [REVISED] Are there warts on Srila Prabhupada's books, or are there no warts? (Warts on Books, Part 4b, 4.28) A difference of opinion (difference of understanding) has arisen- should the books be changed to fix these warts? No changes as the books are perfect? And the warts are only in the minds of the academic editors?
A strong divide has arisen in regards to the "changes" made to Srila Prabhupada's Bhagavad-gita since 1977. I was asked recently about the difference between the two Bhagavad-gitas: "This one was written by Lord Krishna through Srila Prabhupada and the other one I am not sure." I apologise in advance as I admit to being confused, as many of us are, and I was hoping that the audio attached may throw some light.
There is a serious concern as on Saturday 3rd May, 2013 at Bhaktivedanta Manor during class, HH Jayadvaita Maharaj was asked the 84 million dollar question: "When will there be an end to the editing, "changing"? The Definite Bhagavad-gita (Part 4a, 5.20) The answer being, when himself and Dravida prabhu leave their bodies... (Part 4a 6.57) but no guarantee of no changes even then.
Alarm bells are ringing… number of changes already made to the book and a licence to continue. Pictures changed and omitted, Mayavad philosophy inserted and only recently removed, editing out Srila Prabhupada's unique style of language…
I believe HH Jayavaita Maharaj has overstepped the mark, creating division and uncertainty over the law books for the next 10,000 years. Then again, who am I? Not the sharpest pencil in the pack! But this topic should be addressed soon, as in the future there will be great confusion. There is another 10,000 years to go.
Concerns:
1. The ongoing editing, changing and omitting with no end in sight.
2. Creating division in our society.
3. 2.61 purport... Visnu platform added (Mayavad philosophy), only recently changed back to the way it was. Shows that the editors are capable of making serious mistakes.
4. Many places changed or omitted where Srila Prabhupada had actually given class from and had even spoken about the omitted topics.
5. A major concern is that Srila Prabhupada's unique style of language and phrases have been replaced.
Warts on Books, Part 4a (MP3)
Warts on Books, Part 4b (MP3)
Your servant,
Parasuram das
Note from a reader:
The original audios submitted with this article had very very low volume and other background hissing noises that made the audio very difficult to hear, so I tried to fix it. On the Part 4A mp3 there is one small section beginning at 12 minutes and 13 seconds till about 13 minutes that had no sound at all in it, so I removed that empty part that was completely devoid of all speech, otherwise I did no editing at all on the tracks but only removed background hiss sounds, amplified everything and made the stereo tracks into a mono tracks (to shrink the file size), and that's it. Hare Krishna! Your servant, Prahlada-Nrismha das [Ed. The audio files have now been replaced]
